The Evolution Of Bigotry: Racist Tweeting

It’s good to know that technological advancement takes all kinds.

Those who work in CRM (customer relationship management) understand the distinct value of being proactive when it comes to managing both positive and negative conversations happening about a brand or company in the social media space.

People have used social media technology like twitter to collaborate and coordinate and unify people for everything from fun stuff like flash mobs to serious stuff like political and social protests and even revolutions.

And then there are the racists…adopting technology to spread the hate.

A friend of mine posted this “fun” article assessing the geographic frequency of racist tweets following (you guessed it) the presidential election. You can link to it here:

 http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/11/where-americas-racist-tweets-come-from/265006/#.UKFppCRPHPk.facebook
Or simply check out the content below.  I am proud to say I don’t live in the #1 ranking state on the list…although unfortunately didn’t do much better:

Where America’s Racist Tweets Come From

By Megan Garber

inShare66 Nov 9 2012, 12:28 PM ET 334

Warning: The tweets are really, really racist.

[optional image description

A map of the location quotients for racist tweets: the darker-green the state, the higher the location quotient (Floating Sheep)

The day after Barack Obama won a second term as president of the United States, the blog Jezebel published a slideshow. The gallery displayed a collection of screen-capped tweets. Among them was this:

race_1.png

And this:

race_4.png

And this:

race_3.png

There were, both shockingly and unsurprisingly, many more where that came from. And many of those tweets were geocoded: Embedded in them were data about where in the U.S. they were sent from.

Floating Sheep, a group of geography academics, took advantage of that fact to turn hatred — and, just as often, stupidity — into information. The team searched Twitter for racism-revealing terms that appeared in the context of tweets that mentioned “Obama,” “re-elected,” or “won.” That search resulted in (a shockingly high and surprisingly low) 395 tweets. The team then sorted the tweets according to the state they were sent from, comparing the racist tweets to the total number of geocoded tweets coming from that state during the same time period (November 1 – 7). To normalize states across population levels, the team then used a location quotient-inspired measure — an economic derivation used to analyze norms across geographical locations — to compare a state’s racist tweets to the national average of racist tweets.

So, per the team’s model, a score of 1.0 indicates that the state’s proportion of racist tweets to non-racist tweets is the same as the overall national proportion. A score above 1.0 indicates that the proportion of racist tweets to non-racist tweets is higher than the national proportion.

Here’s the LQ formula the team used:

Screen Shot 2012-11-09 at 11.39.21 AM.png

Their findings?

Alabama and Mississippi have the highest LQ measures: They have scores of 8.1 and 7.4, respectively. And the states surrounding these two core states — Georgia, Louisiana, and Tennessee — also have very high LQ scores and form a fairly distinctive cluster in the southeast.

What might be most surprising, though, is the distribution of tweets beyond that cluster. North Dakota and Utah both had relatively high LQ scores (3.5 each), as did Missouri (3). And Oregon and Minnesota, though they don’t score as high when it comes to LQ, have a higher number of hate tweets than their overall Twitter usage would suggest.

In the chart above, the location of individual tweets, indicated by red dots, is overlaid on color-coded states. Yellow shading indicates states that have a relatively low amount of election-oriented hate tweets as compared to their overall tweeting patterns, and the states shaded in green have a higher amount — the darker the green color, the higher the LQ measure.

States shaded in gray had no geocoded hate tweets within the Floating Sheep database, which could have to do with the fact that many of them (Montana, Idaho, Wyoming, and South Dakota) have a relatively low level of Twitter use overall. The analysts also point out that their samples are measuring tweets, rather than authors — so it could be that one user could be responsible for several racist tweets, thus bumping up a state’s numbers. And given the overall low incidence of racist tweets — the good news veiled in all this — once you get past Alabama and Mississippi, it’s worth noting, the variation among the more-racist and less-racist states is relatively small.

Still, though. The analysis is a revealing exercise — and a nice reminder that in the age of the quantified self, biases are just one more thing that can be publicized and analyzed and, finally, judged.

Here, with all that in mind, are the states at the top of the racist-tweet list:

racelist.png

About these ads
Categories: Anthropology, Consumer Anthropology, Consumer Culture, Ethnography, Linguistics, Politics, pop culture, Racism, sociology, Uncategorized | Tags: , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Post navigation

2 thoughts on “The Evolution Of Bigotry: Racist Tweeting

  1. Reblogged this on gfmurphy101 and commented:
    Add your thoughts here… (optional)

  2. Glad Michigan is lowest on the list, but sad that its on there at all.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com. The Adventure Journal Theme.

Millennials at Work

Coming of Age for the Millennial Workforce

Creativenauts

Personal, design, inspiration, interests.

tumsen

Just another WordPress.com site

Echague

fotografias

ThePopularitéBug

Being a popular kid isn't easy,you have to be cautious about every move of yours because you know that all eyes are on you.Not just the eyes that look up to you but also the eyes that love to see you in pain.You might have your own list of followers but with this list there exists the "popularity starved crowd" who wants to replace you.But when reality bites these morons and they're back to square one,hurt and angry with themselves they try to make you the victim of their moment of high adrenaline,just to make you suffer because you're better.They try to clean their head by ruining your perfect life.What's more is right then you realize that none of your "friends" are what they appear to be.You're broken,depressed .You feel the need to talk to someone of your own kind,someone who won't judge you and that's when you can find me at thepopularitébug,I promise to do anything and everything to help you out of your problem!Amen.

Working Self

Creating Meaningful Work with Rebecca Fraser-Thill

AMERICAN MALE

Often described as a blog, an online magazine, a journal when examined further the description changes and it becomes a project, an objective, a mission. American Male is one simple thing. It is a collection of different thoughts and experiences so come share yours and be part of the narrative.

nydwracu niþgrim, nihtbealwa mæst

signals, signals everywhere / and not a thought to think

franceleclerc

Travel and Documentary Photography

franceleclerc

World travel and photography

entitled millennial

"any man can handle adversity; if you want to test his character, give him power"

Thought-Dream Guillotine

A Brain Unfiltered

The High Heel Gourmet

by Miranti Borvornsin, the recipe and menu developer (specialize in Thai foods and Asian fusion) and custom confectionery designer for special events

this man's journey

my past , present and dreams for the future.

Archaeology, Museums & Outreach

Discussions to more effectively engage the public in Archaeology and Museums.

Northstar: Insights to Impact

Someone has to notice

So-Called Millennial

Musings about so-called Millennials

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,500 other followers

%d bloggers like this: